| Player | Pos. | Bats | Throws | Birth Date | Height | Weight | Hometown |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| William Barton | P | 0'0" | 0 | ||||
| Frank Bell | P | 0'0" | 0 | ||||
| Ben Boyd | P | April 8, 1858 | 0'0" | 0 | , MD USA | ||
| Harry Catto | P | February 2, 1865 | 0'0" | 0 | Bordentown, NJ USA | ||
| Ed Chamberlain | P | 0'0" | 0 | ||||
| Nat Collins | P | 0'0" | 0 | ||||
| Davis | P | 0'0" | 0 | ||||
| William Douglass | P | 0'0" | 0 | ||||
| George Evans | P | 0'0" | 0 | ||||
| Fayer | P | 0'0" | 0 | ||||
| Freeman | P | 0'0" | 0 | ||||
| Jack Frye | P | May 0, 1864 | 0'0" | 0 | Harrisburg, PA USA | ||
| Henry Gant | P | 0'0" | 0 | ||||
| Frank Grant | P | R | R | August 1, 1865 | 5'7" | 155 | Pittsfield, MA USA |
| Abe Harrison | P | R | R | March 4, 1867 | 0'0" | 0 | Norristown, PA USA |
| Ben Holmes | P | April 3, 1858 | 0'0" | 0 | King and Queen County, VA USA | ||
| Robert Jackson | P | 0'0" | 0 | ||||
| Will Jackson | P | L | 0'0" | 0 | |||
| Frank Miller | P | December 17, 1865 | 0'0" | 0 | Cumberland, MD USA | ||
| John Nelson | P | 0'0" | 0 | ||||
| Henry Paige | P | 0'0" | 0 | ||||
| George Stovey | P | L | L | May 0, 1866 | 6'0" | 165 | Williamsport, PA USA |
| Winslow Terrill | P | 0'0" | 0 | Boston, MA USA | |||
| Sol White | P | R | R | June 12, 1868 | 5'9" | 170 | Bellaire, OH USA |
| Clarence Williams | P | R | R | January 27, 1866 | 0'0" | 0 | Harrisburg, PA USA |