2004 Mahoning Valley Scrappers Roster

New York-Pennsylvania League (NYPL) - Class: Short Season A
Team Record: 42-34
Finished 2nd in the NYPL's Pinckney Division
Manager: Mike Sarbaugh (42-34)
Affiliation: Cleveland Indians
Location: Niles, Ohio
Ballpark: Eastwood Field
Attendance: 160,832, Avg. 4,232 in 38 home dates
2004 Mahoning Valley Scrappers Statistics

Playoffs - Mahoning Valley Scrappers 2 games, Auburn Doubledays 0
Finals - Mahoning Valley Scrappers 2 games, Tri-City ValleyCats 0

The Mahoning Valley Scrappers of the New York-Pennsylvania League ended the 2004 season with a record of 42 wins and 34 losses, finishing second in the league's Pinckney Division.

The Scrappers tallied 389 runs and allowed 371 runs. Chris Gimenez paced Mahoning Valley with 10 home runs Wyatt Toregas drove in 48 runs. Mike Butia led all qualifying hitters on the roster by hitting .315, while Ryan Knippschild registered a 3.96 earned run average, leading hurlers with significant time on the mound.

Scott Lewis, Chris Gimenez, Tony Sipp, Wyatt Toregas, Aaron Laffey, Brian Tallet, Argenis Reyes, Lou Merloni and Mike Porzio were all players from the 2004 Mahoning Valley Scrappers who played in the Major Leagues during their careers.

Mike Sarbaugh served as manager.


Click on column headings to sort.

Player Bats Throws Birth Date Height Weight Hometown
Mike ButiaLRNovember 29, 19826'2"215Pittsburgh, PA US
Omar CasillasRRSeptember 17, 19836'1"200San Juan, PR
Dan CevetteLLOctober 19, 19836'4"235Wellsboro, PA US
Chris ClemRRFebruary 3, 19846'0"195Brisbane, Queensland AU
Kyle CollinsRRAugust 17, 19816'1"165San Jose, CA US
Jose CruzSROctober 21, 19826'1"180San Juan, PR
Richard De Los SantosRRJune 1, 19846'1"170Comendador, DO
Teodoro EncarnacionRRMarch 26, 19836'2"190Santo Domingo, Distrito Nacional DO
Brian FineganRRDecember 15, 19816'0"190San Jose, CA US
Travis FoleyRRMarch 11, 19836'0"205Louisville, KY US
Chris GimenezRRDecember 27, 19826'2"230Gilroy, CA US
Mariano GomezLLSeptember 12, 19826'6"240San Pedro Sula, HN
Mark HarrisRRFebruary 17, 19816'3"205Cincinnati, OH US
Matt HaynesLRApril 18, 19836'4"200Newcastle, New South Wales AU
Mike HernandezLLApril 8, 19816'4"215Fresno, CA US
Nelson HiraldoRRSeptember 17, 19836'1"195Puerto Plata, DO
Justin HoymanRRApril 17, 19826'3"195Rockledge, FL US
Mark JecmenRRFebruary 16, 19836'8"235Fullerton, CA US
Ryan KnippschildLLSeptember 24, 19826'1"195Sacramento, CA US
Matt KnoxRRDecember 29, 19796'4"220Lebanon, PA US
Aaron LaffeyLLApril 15, 19855'11"190Cumberland, MD US
Scott LewisSLSeptember 26, 19836'0"195West Covina, CA US
Roger LincolnLLJuly 19, 19805'10"175New Haven, CT US
Paul LubranoLLDecember 19, 19816'1"170Winter Springs, FL US
Mario MatulichRRSeptember 22, 19826'3"225Queens, NY US
Lou MerloniRRApril 6, 19715'10"188Framingham, MA US
Tim MontgomeryRRJune 2, 19826'3"210Salem, OR US
Chris NieselRRNovember 18, 19825'11"195Fort Lauderdale, FL US
Fernando PachecoLLOctober 1, 19846'1"205San Diego, CA US
Brett ParkerRRAugust 27, 19806'0"190Mobile, AL US
Justin PekarekRLDecember 4, 19806'4"195Seward, NE US
Todd PenningtonRRApril 6, 19806'2"220McClure, IL US
Mike PorzioLLAugust 20, 19726'3"190Waterbury, CT US
Argenis ReyesSRSeptember 25, 19825'10"180Santiago, Santiago DO
Scott RoehlRRAugust 19, 19816'1"195Kenosha, WI US
Hector SantanaRRJuly 13, 19826'0"160San Pedro de Macoris, San Pedro de Macoris DO
Tony SippLLJuly 12, 19836'0"190Pascagoula, MS US
Chip SoutherlandRRMay 3, 19826'3"230Roseburg, OR US
Marshall SzaboSRFebruary 13, 19835'11"180Alpharetta, GA US
Brian TalletLLSeptember 21, 19776'6"220Midwest City, OK US
Wyatt ToregasRRDecember 2, 19825'11"210Fairfax, VA US

Average attendance is based upon the number of actual home dates where known (most leagues from 1992 and later). Where the number of home dates is not known, the average is calculated using half the team's total games.



Minor League Baseball


Minor League Baseball Search

Latest News

Scrappers Egg Hunt on April 2nd Location Changed to Eastwood Event Centre at Eastwood Mall Complex - Tickets Are Sold Out
Posted on Friday March 27, 2026

NILES, OH - The Scrappers Egg Hunt on Thursday, April 2nd will now take place at the Eastwood Event Centre at the Eastwood Mall Complex. The Egg Hunt ...

Scrappers Announce Ernie Clement Bobblehead Giveaway on Saturday, June 20
Posted on Thursday March 26, 2026

Niles, OH - The Mahoning Valley Scrappers are excited to announce a special Ernie Clement bobblehead giveaway on Saturday, June 20 at 7 17 Credit Unio...

Joe Thurston to Manage the Mahoning Valley Scrappers for the 2026 Season
Posted on Tuesday March 17, 2026

NILES, OH - Former Major Leaguer, Joe Thurston, has been named Manager for the Mahoning Valley Scrappers for the 2026 season.Thurston was selected...